Last Updated on 2 months
Can You Use Winter Tires Year-Round? Pros and Cons
A common misconception about winter tires is that they are suitable for use all year-round. While they can technically be used in the summer, it’s not idea. Winter tires are designed to perform their best in freezing temperatures, unlike all-season tires, which can be used in hot and cold weather. Understanding the benefits of winter tires and why their best suited for colder months is essential if you frequent colder areas. Here’s everything you need to know about winter tires throughout the year.
What Makes A Winter Tire
Winter tires are a class of automotive tires made of unique rubber compounds designed to maintain flexibility in cold temperatures. They typically feature unique tread patterns and thread designs to enhance grip on snow and ice, providing extra stability. However, when used in summer or warmer weather, they’re basically out of their element. This doesn’t mean that they are unusable, but it does mean that their performance will fall short of expectations.
Pros of Using Winter Tires Year-Round
Let’s start by discussing the potential advantages of keeping your winter tires on your vehicle throughout the year.
1) No Need for Seasonal Tire Swaps
One of the main reasons some drivers choose to keep winter tires on year-round is convenience. Switching between winter and all-season or summer tires twice yearly requires effort, time, and money.
2) No Need For Storage
Seasonal tire changes also require space to store the unused tires, which can be inconvenient if you don’t have a dedicated storage area. Using winter tires year-round eliminates the need to worry about changing and storing tires every six months.
3) Marginally More Grip in Rain
Due to their design, winter tires can provide more traction in slippery conditions, including rainy weather. The deep tread patterns of winter tires help channel water away from the tire, reducing the risk of hydroplaning. This is most noticeable when the winter tires are new, so the slits and sharp edges of the treads can easily cut through the water. In regions where it rains frequently during spring and summer, the superior water-channeling ability of new winter tires can be somewhat beneficial.
4) Emergency Preparedness
Keeping winter tires on year-round is a practical solution for drivers living in unpredictable weather. In some regions, spring snowstorms or early fall frosts can bring unexpected winter-like conditions. With winter tires still on your vehicle, you won’t be caught off guard if a sudden cold front brings snow or ice. Even though this rarely happens, drivers in specific regions could benefit from having winter tires on.
Cons of Using Winter Tires Year-Round
While using winter tires in warmer months has some potential advantages, the drawbacks far outweigh the benefits.
1) Decreased Performance in Warm Weather
Winter tires are specifically engineered for cold temperatures, so they don’t perform optimally when the mercury rises. Their softer rubber compound, which remains flexible in winter, becomes overly pliable in warmer conditions.
- Poor Handling: The soft rubber reduces handling precision in warm weather. You may notice that your vehicle feels “sluggish” or unresponsive during cornering, particularly at higher speeds.
- Longer Braking Distances: Winter tires increase braking distances in warm conditions. The softer rubber causes the tires to “squirm” during hard braking, making it harder for your vehicle to stop quickly.
- Increased Risk of Hydroplaning: While winter tires perform well in the rain, the excess softness in warm conditions can result in more tire flex, reducing their effectiveness in wet conditions.
2) Accelerated Tire Wear
Premature wear is one of the most significant downsides of using winter tires year-round. Because winter tires are designed with softer rubber compounds, they wear out much faster in warm weather.
- Tread Life: Winter tires typically last around 20,000 to 30,000 miles when used in their intended conditions. However, their tread life could be reduced by 30% to 50% if used year-round.
- Cost Factor: Constantly replacing worn-out winter tires can cost more in the long run than switching between summer and winter tires, as recommended.
3) Reduced Fuel Efficiency
Winter tires are less fuel-efficient than summer or all-season tires because of their increased rolling resistance. The soft rubber compounds and deeper tread patterns make winter tires heavier and less aerodynamic, causing your engine to work harder to maintain speed.
- Fuel Consumption: Studies have shown that vehicles running on winter tires in warm weather can experience a 5% to 10% increase in fuel consumption.
- Environmental Impact: Increased fuel consumption costs you more at the pump and contributes to a larger carbon footprint.
4) Noisy Ride
Winter tires are typically noisier than summer or all-season tires. The aggressive tread design provides excellent traction in snow and ice but creates more road noise in dry, warm conditions.
- Comfort Factor: This increase in road noise can make long road trips or daily commutes less enjoyable, especially on highways where tire noise is more noticeable.
Legal Restrictions in Some Areas
In some regions, studded winter tires are prohibited after specific dates because they can damage road surfaces. If you have studded winter tires, you may face fines or penalties for using them outside the permitted winter months.
Should You Use Winter Tires Year-Round?
In conclusion, it is possible to use winter tires year-round, but it is not recommended. Winter tires are specifically designed for cold weather, snow, and ice, and using them in warm weather compromises safety, performance, and cost-efficiency. The cons of using winter tires year-round—such as decreased handling, longer braking distances, rapid tire wear, and reduced fuel efficiency—make it clear that they are not suited for all-season use. The best approach is to swap out winter tires for all-season or summer tires once temperatures consistently rise above 45°F (7°C).
